|
Source
|
Advantages
|
Disadvantages
|
| Coal |
- Inexpensive
- Easy to recover (in U.S. and Russia)
|
- Requires expensive air pollution controls (e.g. mercury,
sulfur dioxide)
- Significant contributor to acid rain and global warming
- Requires extensive transportation system
|
| Nuclear |
- Fuel is inexpensive
- Energy generation is the most concentrated source
- Waste is more compact than any source
- Extensive scientific basis for the cycle
- Easy to transport as new fuel
- No greenhouse or acid rain effects
|
- Requires larger capital cost because of emergency,
containment, radioactive waste and storage systems
- Requires resolution of the long-term high level waste
storage issue in most countries
- Potential nuclear proliferation issue
|
| Hydroelectric |
- Very inexpensive once dam is built
- Government has invested heavily in building dams,
particularly in the Western U.S.
|
- Very limited source since depends on water elevation
- Many dams available are currently exist (not much of a
future source[depends on country])
- Dam collapse usually leads to loss of life
- Dams have affected fish (e.g. salmon runs)
- Environmental damage for areas flooded (backed up) and
downstream
|
| Gas / Oil |
- Good distribution system for current use levels
- Easy to obtain (sometimes)
- Better as space heating energy source
|
- Very limited availability as shown by shortages during
winters several years ago
- Could be major contributor to global warming
- Very expensive for energy generation
- Large price swings with supply and demand
- Liquified Natural Gas storage facilities and gas
transmission systems have met opposition from environmentalists.
|
| Wind |
- Wind is free if available. As it turns out, the US has many
areas available.
- Good source for periodic water pumping demands of farms as
used earlier in 1900's
- Generation and maintenance costs have decreased
significantly. Wind is proving to be a reasonable cost renewable
source.
- Well suited to rural areas. Examples include Mid-Columbia
areas of Oregon and Washington, western Minnesota, Atlantic
Ocean off Cape Cod.
|
- Need 3x the amount of installed generation to meet demand
- Limited to windy areas.
- Limited to small generator size; need many towers.
- Highly climate dependent - wind can damage equipment during
windstorms or not turn during still summer days.
- May affect endangered birds, however tower design can reduce
impact..
|
| Solar |
- Sunlight is free when available
- Costs are dropping.
|
- Limited to southern areas of U.S. and other sunny areas
throughout the world (demand can be highest when least
available, e.g. winter solar heating)
- Does require special materials for mirrors/panels that can
affect environment
- Current technology requires large amounts of land for small
amounts of energy generation
|
| Biomass |
- Industry in its infancy
- Could create jobs because smaller plants would be used
|
- Inefficient if small plants are used
- Could be significant contributor to global warming because
fuel has low heat content
|
| Refuse Based Fuel |
- Fuel can have low cost
- Could create jobs because smaller plants would be used
- Low sulfur dioxide emissions
|
- Inefficient if small plants are used
- Could be significant contributor to global warming because
fuel has low heat content
- Flyash can contain metals as cadmium and lead
- Contain dioxins and furans in air and ash releases
|
| Hydrogen |
- Combines easily with oxygen to produce water and energy
|
- Very costly to produce
- Takes more energy to produce hydrogen then energy that could
be recovered.
|
| Fusion |
- Hydrogen and tritium could be used as fuel source
- Higher energy output per unit mass than fission
- Low radiation levels associated with process than
fission-based reactors
|
- Breakeven point has not been reached after ~40 years of
expensive research
|